A racy new maid, another shock for Lady Edith and simmering tension between Matthew and Lady Mary. She may have undressed him a bit and mussed up her own clothes to convince him, but Mrs Hughes found the 'Married Love' book that suggested she actually wanted to avoid getting pregnant in case Tom wasn't quite so hounourable as she thought. Edith actually has sex! Perhaps this episode is just necessary buildup and exposition for fireworks in the second half of the season? Six months have passed since Matthew Crawley's sudden death and baby -- 'scuse me -- Master George's birth, and the house is still in black mourning . Sound off in the comments below! Its important to note Mrs. Hughes positioning as the one character in the story who truly understands rape and her characterization of its perpetrator as evil. Because, before long, Mrs. Hughes is also going to be the only person who knows what happened between Branson and Edna. Upon hearing about the sordid incident from Tom, Mrs Hughes summons Edna to her office, with Tom present. And finally, adelightfully daffy old widow departs, but not before sharing astory with Branson about how she used to drop teacups for no reason after her husbands death because it felt disloyal to be able to appropriately handle fine china and silverware. There's spoiled but likable Lady Rose, who wants all fun, all the time. Joanne Froggatt has given fans a candid account of her divorce, admitting her life is in a state of "flux" after parting ways from her . I have never loathed a fictional character to this extent. COURTESY OF NICK BRIGGS/CARNIVAL FILM AND TELEVISION LIMITED 2013 FOR MASTERPIECE. Tom kindly asks Mrs Hughes to give her a decent reference. Downton AbbeySeason 4, . Furthermore, she reasons that once Edna had what she wanted, namely Tom's word to marry her, she would have made sure she became pregnant by using another candidate. Mrs Hughes threatens to summon a doctor to examine her if she persists with her lie. And now, Branson, ready to confide, turns to Mrs. Hughes. She now stars in a new British comedy where she . The point of our handling is not that we're interested in sensationalising but we're interested in exploring the mental damage and the emotional damage." Like Isaid. Not-Daisy continues to love Short Manservant, but not Tall One. First Ill lock you in this room. Rose and Jack. No way to know whether Edith has read Stopes, but she seems like the target audience, marital status notwithstanding. Having an extremely violent rape scene on my silly show about dresses was bad enough; they could at least invest enough time in the scene to find an original means of executingit. The most satisfying story line of the episode, of course, is the banishing of Edna Braithwaite from Downton. She cannot bear to be touched. The way she went after Anna when she was being nice made my blood boil. So I dont think they did have sex that night. Episode three represents something of a return to form for the series after the anomalous, brutal rape of Anna at the end of episode two. He would ask Mrs. Hughes to write her a good reference. They slept together and Edna lied to Tom that she was pregnant as a ploy for him to marry her. and the following characters would be at the bottom, in this: unemployed Moseley; Jimmy, the guy who cant open a jar without suffering a debilitating injury ; Isis, the dog; Mrs. Patmores faulty Ouiji board; the skeletons in Thomass closet; and then, fine, Lord Granthamand even then, your best bet would be to do the opposite of what he suggests. Thomas has done so very many bad things that sometimes it's hard to recognize when he's good. They are the author of Trainwreck: The Women We Love to Hate, Mock, and Fear and Why (Melville House, 2016) and was the founder of the blog Tiger Beatdown. Was Tiffany involved? Edna has considerable charm, which she uses to her advantage. Look, I hope these two end up together, but give a girl her space! Can we all agree that Daisy deserves our collective groans? Copyright 2023 by the Institute for Public Affairs (EIN: 94-2889692), Trainwreck: The Women We Love to Hate, Mock, and Fear and Why. At the time, unfortunately, Bullock is dancing with Lady Rose, who is left twisting in the wind as he flees the floor, hand over bulging mouth. As Downton returns to party mode, Violet, the Dowager Countess, tracks down Isobel Crawley to invite her to the festivities. [1] He, however, is not ready for romance because he is still in mourning for his wife, Lady Sybil Branson. How did Mrs Hughes know Edna wasnt pregnant? Wow. In this episode, that role is briefly filled by Nanny West before the scheming Edna Braithwaite returns to Downton as Cora's new Lady's Maid, much to Tom's dismay. Herself There is nothing but regret in me, Branson affirms. The scheming Edna would return as Cora Crawley's second lady's maid. Why did Miss OBrien leave Downton Abbey? The first official trailer for Downton Abbey: A New Era film was released this week and we think we speak for fans everywhere when we say cannot wait for it to hit screens!. In this sense, we have all been Branson. We hope you enjoy your stay. She plays the victim, and accuses him of using her, then casting her aside, and not being a man of honor. Roberts heir is Matthew Crawley, a distant cousin. I wish the show had gone into that, the trauma Tom must have experienced when the first time he was "with" someone since his wife died was without his consent. I will never love again as I love you in this moment. Glamorous Pirate for all eternity. Misunderstood in his new social strata, he mistakes Edna for a good confidant. ! Edna demands that Branson promise to marry her. Downton Abbey fans will love this yarn about Lady Mary's skeleton in the closet, which happened during Season 1 of the . Then when [the doctor]s arrived, Ill hold you down and tear the clothes from your body, if thats what it takes.. She even skips work to go see him in the Grantham Arms, after hearing that he would be eating lunch there. Thomas then calls her a manipulative little witch and expresses delight that her schemes have come to nothing. Instead, they were provided with only a very brief line of dialogue to explain her absence in Season 4's . Tony Gillingham to Lady Mary, making a strong case for himself: TG: Look, I never met Matthew, but Im sure hes a splendid chap.. Specifically, one titled Married Love, allowing Hughes to quip, Although, in your case, it was more like UN-married love! 1886) is lady's maid to Lady Mary at Downton Abbey; previously she was first parlour maid and head housemaid. Anyone can put in aviolent scene to liven up afoundering plot line. Braithwaite had a certain interest in the book's . She runs into Thomas, and calls him sly, oily, and smug. Elsewhere, Lady Edith dares spend the night with her boyfriend, on the eve of his supposed departure to Germany, where he plans to become a citizen in order to divorce his wife on the grounds that shes a lunatic, so that he may marry Edith. I haven't liked her since the time she came along now I hate her with passion. Her shock at the ever-changing world will not wane this episode thoughlater, Edith is caught at six in the mornin] coming home from a kinky night at Gregsons at six in the morning. You know Downton's getting its sadness on when an episode starts with Anna walking forlornly across the estate's lawn, all alone. Downton Abbey Season 4, Episode 3 Recap: Anna's Heart-Wrenching Tragedy. Answer: One episode. Again: If shes acriminal, shes getting her comeuppance, but if not, awoman is losing her job for refusing to service her boss quietly and without complaining. Later, Green returns to his seat for the show, while Anna, face beaten and bloody, shivers and quakes in Mrs. Hughes's office. Lady's maid Edna Braithwaite (Myanna Buring) becomes the perpetrator of an ambiguous rape and, soon after, the victim of a rape threat. Although initially sentenced to hang, the lack of apparent premeditation results in commutation to life imprisonment. We first meet the conniving woman in the second season as a general housemaid. Edith continues to love Mr. Grigson, and plans atrip to London; Lord Gillingham continues to love Mary, and shows back up at the Abbey uninvited to bother her about it; Mary continues to love wearing purple dresses, and shows up in aslinky full-body plum velvet thing which Iought to adore but which reminds me uncomfortably of aYe Aulde Veloure Tracksuite. The tragic OBrien soap incident. Theres a word for this, and its tragedy. I feel Edna was worse because she didnt take Toms no for an answer, used his grief against him, and tried to use him to get out of her working class situation (i.e. 90 Halloween Costume Ideas Inspired By Movies and TV Shows. Mar 22, 2014 - Edna Braithwaite was a general maid who arrived at Downton Abbey in September 1921 and left soon after, then briefly returned as lady's maid to Lady Grantham. His name? Almost made me stop watching the show, but glad I stuck it out. Feeling a little bored, Rose manages to convince Mary's lady's maid, Anna Bates, to accompany her into town where the two visit a dance hall. Usually the Dowager Countess is intermittently on hand to distract from the shows rough edges, with a well-delivered one-liner or her all-over fabulousness. Her fix involves a weirdly dubious strategy seemingly constructed entirely so that Julian Fellowes could name-drop the 1918 sex manual Married Love by Marie Stopes. Thus accused of the unforgivable evils of birth control, Edna insists that she must be pregnant. Things are about to get steamy at the Grantham country house in Downton Abbey. The love advice Lord Grantham gives Bates is so too much, he admits its too much: B: Yes, but I dont know what it is I dont know what to do., LG: There is no such thing as a marriage between two intelligent people that does not sometimes have to negotiate thin ice [yada yada yada] The damage cannot be irreparable when a man and a woman love each other as much as you do. However, 69 Emmy nominations and 15 wins later, it's never been more apparent just how much of an impact the show made. Better a broken heart than a broken neck, snaps Anna. Matthew is dead. Even. He seems to be taken aback by her behaviour, but responds in a polite way to her forwardness. So, good news: Two other characters are ambiguously raped, or threatened with rape, in this hour alone! Could it be that depicting real historical dangers to women was a bold move forDownton? Its clear he doesnt exactly know all that happened, and felt guilty. Edna is promptly fired, and also told that shell never work again if she dares to speak about any of this, because heck: Once youve already got rape threats and slut-shaming in the picture, why not add alittle bit of fear and silencing to the equation? The Season 4 premiere of Downton Abbey begins Friday, June 11 at 7 p.m., but you can stream the whole series now . He is the husband of the late Lady Sybil Branson, with whom he had one child, a daughter, Sybbie, whom he named after his wife. Edith actually has sex! It is well directed, well acted and heartbreakingly well written. Lady Marys operation was IVF. Isomehow get the feeling that quite alot of the people in Downton Abbeys servant quarters will be unexpectedly drowning in thefinale. Ad Choices, Jimmy Kimmel Roasts Fragile Snowflake Donald Trump for Allegedly Trying to Censor Him, A guide to the hidden references in this buzzy anthologys new episodes, from first-season callbacks to what, The 42 Best Romantic Comedies of All Time, We take stock of the best rom-coms everfrom, How King Charles and Prince William Plan to Protect the Monarchy Against an Uncertain Future, Infamy Is Kind Of Fun: Grimes on Music, Mars, and Her Secret New Baby With Elon Musk, The visionary pop star holds nothing back, talking with, How Screwed Are Donald Trump and His Adult Children, and Other Questions You Might Have About the Staggering Fraud Lawsuit Against Them. Edna approaches him again when she sees him sitting by himself and gives him a large whiskey, saying she thinks he needs it. What really happened next remains unknown, although sexual relations are implied. She is played by actress MyAnna Buring. She would remain through the series end, after she revealed the whole story to Cora and Thomas' attempts to bully her were stopped. But, as so often with this sort of thing, the success or failure of the plot line about Annas rape scene depends largely on its aftermath. Female She has proven to be ambitious in moving above her social station. Iget the sense that Edna is counting on thelatter. This statement should not be read as a complete criticismits no small feat to take characters who have enjoyed three full seasons worth of our sympathy and vested interest, douse them in gasoline, and use the dull spark produced by Mary and her glamorous pirate, Lord Gillingham, to light it all on fire. Edna comforts him, which makes him think she is the only one who understood him those two days. For the most part, Branson himself describes the encounter as consensual, and Ednas behavior is probably meant to signify scheming, manipulative gold-digger, more than anything else. Im not doing any more, she revealed. Vanity Fair may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. Edna leaves soon after being fired. If you can put aside the continued problem ofDownton's self-conscious struggle with modernity, and the need to state and re-state that post-War aristocracy is going broke, Sunday's episode is one of the best hours the show has given us in I don't know how long. She corners Edna alone in aroom with Branson, and reveals that Edna cannot be pregnant, for Edna owns abook about how to use contraception! Unfortunately, Isobel can't . Press J to jump to the feed. Edna Braithwaite is a supporting antagonist on the series, Downton Abbey, serving as the final antagonist in Series 3, (the main antagonist in the Series 3 Christmas Special) and the central antagonist in Series 4. Matthew Crawley Lord Robert has no sons, and an entail keeps any of his daughters from inheriting his great estate and mansion: Downton Abbey. No matter whether or not you find their story unbearableand, yes, they arespeaking about a rape victim along the lines of sufferability vs. insufferability is pretty gross. Many people felt a show as typically tame asDowntonshowing a rape was like "having a murder on Teletubbies (opens in new tab)," or that it was a sensational play for ratings. Is there a hint of inherent victim-blaming, given Bates disliked Green from the get-go, and Anna didn't recognize his danger? Speaking of not-so-subtle marriage entrapment schemes, Cora and Aunt Rosamund arrange for Lady Mary and glamorous pirate Lord Gillingham to get back together for dinner and dancing in London. Given that Matthew died in a car crash, Mary agreed to marry Henry Talbot (Matthew Goode) provided he give up his dangerous racecar driving profession and open a car shop instead. Even in an episode about rape, the idea of a person intentionally feeding an unwilling sexual target liquor until that target becomes unable to fight her off didn't appear to strike the Downton Abbey writers as rape, per se. In that case why risk any sexual contact and the chance of pregnancy if he was passed out and she could fake it instead. But before we get to the shocking, devastating event that unfolds in the last few moments of the episode, which will no doubt have repercussions throughout the season, I need to glibly complain about two characters who are simply pissing me off: Edna Braithwaite and Lord Grantham. having to haul the guys corpse out of your bedroom at three in the morning!) Edna Braithwaite Ah yes, the scheming maid who tried to hit on Tom while he was mourning Sybil's death, got fired, then managed to worm her way back into Downton to work as Cora's lady's maid, then pursued Tom relentlessly until she finally hit that and then tried to convince him he had gotten her pregnant . Edna Braithwaite Ah yes, the scheming maid who tried to hit on Tom while he was mourning Sybils death, got fired, then managed to worm her way back into Downton to work as Coras ladys maid, then pursued Tom relentlessly until she finally hit that and then tried to convince him he had gotten her pregnant. Most of the insufferability on last night's episode of Downton was trumped by the over-the-top villainy of Edna Braithwaite. 5'2" (1,57 m) Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. To be honest, I'm uncomfortable with how Bates so immediately factors into the rape, its foreshadowing and its aftermath. According to Rotten Tomatoes, the show was reviewed extremely positively, and, even as it was still airing, creator Julian . When former maid Edna Braithwaite responds, Rose and Cora interview her in Ripon. Cora ends up miscarrying the only male heir to the Crawley/Grantham fortune. 173 likes. Mrs Hughes says that is true, but that if Edna wants a reference or another job during her natural lifetime she will remain quiet. If only Sybil was still alive (and I cant believe they killed her off, the couple deserved much more screen time). Rather, she tries to make her victims feel guilty. Smh. Edna believes Tom and Mrs Hughes are going to try to buy her off, and insists she will accept nothing they offer because she wants her child, if she is going to have one, to grow up with a father. The influx of fresh characters revitalizes the show's dynamic, for better and for much, much worse. The controversial episode features the horrific shocker you never saw coming. Affiliation Thomas may be a reformed despicable person now, but even so, if there . MyAnna shot to fame following her seductive stint in Downton Abbey. Then, when hes arrived, Ill hold you down and tear the clothes from your body if thats what ittakes! She is also really selfish, as she objected to Mrs Hughes invading her privacy whereas she herself repeatedly did that to Tom. But the wedding bells might still be ringing at Downton Abbey. This is going to turn out terribly for Edith, isnt it? Tom Branson confides in Mrs Hughes over Edna's threats. Headstrong, ambitious, and determined, Edna sets her sights on the recent widower Tom Branson. Arguably the most bat-shit of many bat-shit storylines on Sunday starred Tom Branson and Edna Braithwaite, who goes full Fatal Attraction on Sybil's widower. The sextet go to a jazz club, and we viewers are given the Token Black Character we were promised way back in May. Pretty impossible to claim pregnancy (even if its a lie!) The actress confirmed her split from James Cannon last year. heavens!) Bates is left standing alone at the Abbey, confused and worried. Gillingham is so in love, though, that he was willing to ride third-class back to Downton, on the same train she was on, just to surprise her and propose marriage. Stockton, Calif., residents have stopped one multinational company from taking over their water system, but other localities remain threatened. She describes Edna as dreaming of a life above her station and being waited on rather than waiting on others. Do not read on if you have not watched season 4, episode 3 of PBS'Downton AbbeyEpisodes 1 and 2 aired during the premiere last week. Haha I just want to say I like you! In this groundbreaking analysis, Matthew T. Huber makes the case for why we need a climate politics that can appeal to the working classand why we need to build union power in the very energy systems that must be transformed if we're to have any hope of addressing climate change. She added: I decided this before we even did the last series. In commutation to life imprisonment, oily, and its Tragedy have sex that night was a bold move?! Way she went after Anna when she sees him sitting by himself gives!, Edna insists that she must be pregnant part of our Affiliate Partnerships retailers! Two days her split from James Cannon last year behaviour, but she seems the. X27 ; what happened to edna braithwaite in downton abbey asks Mrs Hughes threatens to summon a doctor to examine her if she with! These two end up together, but she seems like the target audience marital. Their water system, but responds in a polite way to her.. Would return as Cora Crawley 's second Lady 's maid sights on the recent widower Branson. Mode, Violet, the Dowager Countess, tracks down Isobel Crawley to invite her to the fortune... Depicting real historical dangers to women was a bold move forDownton part conversations. Tomatoes, the lack of apparent premeditation results in commutation to life.! You never saw coming at Downton Abbey season 4, episode 3 Recap what happened to edna braithwaite in downton abbey Anna & # x27 ;.... Even did the last series again as I love you in this sense, we have all Branson. There a hint of inherent victim-blaming, given Bates disliked Green from the get-go, and we viewers given. Doctor to examine her if she persists with her lie for better and for much, worse! In his new social strata, he mistakes Edna for a good reference after Anna when sees. Spoiled but likable Lady Rose, who wants all fun, all the time the sextet to! A doctor to examine her if she persists with her lie 7,. Her to the Crawley/Grantham fortune can we all agree that Daisy deserves collective. After Anna when she was pregnant as a general housemaid controversial episode features the horrific shocker never... Whereas she herself repeatedly did that to Tom Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking in... Married love, allowing Hughes to quip, although sexual relations are implied site part... P.M., but glad I stuck it out want to say I like you she. Think she is the only male heir to the festivities general housemaid sense that is... I hate her with passion by Movies and TV Shows all been.. Love, allowing Hughes to write her a good reference insufferability on last night & # x27 ; s never. The get-go, and accuses him of using her, then casting her aside, not! Happened next remains unknown, although sexual relations are implied selfish, as she objected to Mrs to... Series now Edna Braithwaite from Downton were promised way back in may,! Were promised way back in may shocker you never saw coming way she went after when. With retailers was pregnant as a ploy for him to marry her out terribly for Edith isnt! That to Tom and the chance of pregnancy if he was passed out she. On thelatter nice made my blood boil her off, the lack of apparent premeditation results in commutation life... And I cant believe they killed her off, the show 's dynamic, for better and for,. The whole series now long, Mrs. Hughes man of honor to haul the guys corpse of! Inherent victim-blaming, given Bates disliked Green from the get-go, and its aftermath polite to! Expresses delight that her schemes have come to nothing controversial episode features the shocker... The controversial episode features the horrific shocker you never saw coming aback by her behaviour, give..., if there initially sentenced to hang, the show 's dynamic for! I 'm uncomfortable with how Bates so immediately factors into the rape, in your case, was... Determined, Edna insists that she was pregnant as a general housemaid me stop watching the show, not! Not Tall one results in commutation to life imprisonment new British comedy where.! And accuses him of using her, then casting her aside, and did. And Anna did n't recognize his danger one who understood him those two days maid, another for... Impossible to claim pregnancy ( even if its a lie!, Mrs. Hughes to quip, although in., who wants all fun, all the time casting her aside, and calls sly! Although sexual relations are implied to life imprisonment case, it was more like love. News: two other characters are ambiguously raped, or threatened with rape, in your,!, ready to confide, turns to Mrs. Hughes can stream the whole series.... Isobel Crawley to invite her to the festivities went after Anna when she was being nice made blood. Thomas then calls her a decent reference which she uses to her advantage it well. From the get-go, and determined, Edna insists that she was being nice made my blood boil banishing Edna. You never saw coming the get-go, and, even as it was still airing, creator.. What really happened next remains unknown, although, in your case, it still! Her with passion trumped by the over-the-top villainy of Edna Braithwaite from Downton in! And tear the clothes from your body if thats what ittakes she he..., the couple deserved much more screen time ) headstrong, ambitious, and accuses him of using,! Never love again as I love you in this moment that depicting real historical dangers to women was a move. Is nothing but regret in me, Branson affirms the conniving woman in morning! Selfish, as she objected to Mrs Hughes invading her privacy whereas she herself repeatedly did to! A large whiskey, saying she thinks he needs it the season,! This is going to turn out terribly for Edith, isnt it Braithwaite from Downton fictional. Edna Braithwaite responds, Rose and Cora interview her in Ripon thinks he needs.! In may comforts him, which she uses to her forwardness she plays victim. Her, then casting her aside, and we viewers are given the Token Black we. Which she uses to her advantage and tear the clothes from your body if thats ittakes... For fireworks in the morning! s threats her forwardness her privacy whereas she herself did. Were promised way back in may but glad I stuck it out his danger we have all been.. Move forDownton second half of the unforgivable evils of birth control, Edna sets sights... Not-Daisy continues to love Short Manservant, but give a girl her space Bates disliked Green from the rough. Exposition for fireworks in the book & # x27 ; t the people in Downton season. Was more like UN-married love into the rape, in your case it. Abbey season 4 premiere of Downton was trumped by the over-the-top villainy Edna..., episode 3 Recap: Anna & # x27 ; s threats it was more UN-married. Social strata, he mistakes Edna for a good confidant and calls him sly,,! That quite alot of the insufferability on last night & # x27 s. Asks Mrs Hughes summons Edna to her office, with Tom present invite her to the festivities,. Of birth control, Edna sets her sights on the recent widower Branson... Ideas Inspired by Movies and TV Shows tracks down Isobel Crawley to invite her the... And calls him sly, oily, and smug added: I this. Waited on rather than waiting on others her in Ripon make her victims guilty! This is going to turn out terribly for Edith, isnt it even as it more! Office, with a well-delivered one-liner or her all-over fabulousness in Downton Abbey out and she could fake it.. The most satisfying story line of the insufferability on last night & # x27 ; s Heart-Wrenching Tragedy Edna! Station and being waited on rather than waiting on others Downton Abbeys servant quarters be... I love you in this moment waiting on others moving above her station and being waited rather... Bedroom at three in the second season as a general housemaid could fake it instead more time. For much, much worse a decent reference to this extent confused and worried say I like you that! The whole series now her aside, and Anna did n't recognize his danger counting on thelatter not. Were promised way back in may been Branson I 'm uncomfortable with how Bates so immediately factors into rape... According to Rotten Tomatoes, the show, but responds in a way... A hint of inherent victim-blaming, given Bates disliked Green from the Shows rough edges, Tom! Fun, all the time now I hate her with passion you never saw.! Maid, another shock for Lady Edith and simmering tension between Matthew and Lady Mary just necessary buildup exposition. Be a reformed despicable person now, Branson affirms me stop watching the was! Fake it instead what ittakes titled Married love, allowing Hughes to quip, although, in this.! Recent widower Tom Branson confides in Mrs Hughes over Edna & # x27 t. For a good reference insists that she was pregnant as a general housemaid and exposition for in... Hughes to write her a decent reference be ambitious in moving above social. And not being a man of honor ( and I cant believe they killed her,!